Breaking news: Bush Just Says No, as rightly he should. I don't like the word "defies" in this link's headline. Bush has absolutely no reason to say "yes." He has every reason to assert his private conversations in the Oval Office are private, just as Nancy Pelosi does in her office.
Saying no is saying no. "Defying" Congress is so not the issue here and shows the headline writer hasn't a clue what's really going on.
But it will ultimately go to the Supreme Court for yet another ruling.
I firmly believe that unless there are some conversations, some communications that are private then everything from the President's office should be piped directly into Congress.
That Congress thinks it is privy to each and everything is utterly ridiculous, and getting more ridiculous every day. And if it were so, it would be the undoing. of our country.